Improving service quality must precede benefit increases for employment system
A study by the Korea Institute of Public Finance suggests that improving the quality of counseling services at employment centers is more critical for the National Employment Support System than increasing benefits or expanding eligibility.
The Korea Institute of Public Finance found that the National Employment Support System has shown minimal effectiveness in leading to actual employment. Researchers warned that increasing benefits or beneficiaries without first improving the quality of counseling services at frontline employment centers could actually increase the unemployment rate.
While the National Employment Support System, introduced in 2021, aims to support youth employment, its effectiveness in leading to actual employment beyond simple income support has appeared minimal. Analysis suggests that before expanding the pool of beneficiaries or increasing job-seeking promotion benefits, efforts to strengthen the substance of the system by improving the quality of counseling services at frontline employment centers must come first.
According to the research titled "Performance and Policy Implications of the National Employment Support System: Focusing on Young People" released by the Korea Institute of Public Finance, the National Employment Support System is a fiscal support job program that simultaneously provides employment support services and income support to vulnerable groups. As of 2025, the project budget is at the level of 845.7 billion won, with a significant number of participants concentrated among youth aged 15 to 34.
Ensuring service efficiency is key before increasing benefits
Theoretical analysis conducted by researchers using a labor market model confirmed that expanding the system could actually increase the unemployment rate within the economy. This is because the expansion of the system may also affect the job-seeking probability of non-beneficiaries. It was pointed out that if the effects of the system are estimated by simply comparing beneficiary and non-beneficiary groups, there is a risk that the system's effectiveness may be overestimated.
When an analysis was performed by setting up additional comparison groups alongside the actual treatment and control groups, no statistically significant effect was found regarding the National Employment Support System's ability to increase the probability of employment. The analysis suggests it is highly likely that the impact of the system itself on the overall labor market has been limited.
In particular, researchers examined the actual state of system operations through in-depth interviews with counselors at employment centers. The analysis observed that in the field, operations tended to lean toward supporting the livelihoods of vulnerable groups rather than focusing on the core functions and roles of employment services. It appears that improving the quality of employment services has been pushed down in priority.
Need for increased counseling staff and customized training
Researchers derived directions for system improvement through policy experiments using their model. The analysis showed that increasing job-seeking promotion benefits or employment success benefits without first improving the efficiency of employment support services is not desirable in terms of the unemployment rate or social welfare. Conversely, if service efficiency is improved, there is sufficient room to increase total social welfare by expanding the number of beneficiaries.
Consequently, the study concluded that to resolve youth employment issues, qualitative improvements in employment services for young people must be actively pursued before pursuing an expansion of beneficiaries or benefit increases. To achieve this, it was suggested that employment centers should secure and deploy an appropriate level of counseling staff and seek organizational management and work distribution methods suited to the circumstances of individual centers.
Furthermore, the researchers emphasized the need for investment in customized education and training to maintain and enhance the capabilities of counseling staff, and that active participation of participants should be encouraged by preparing programs that meet the demands of young job seekers. Additionally, the analysis suggests that performance management indicators and systems should be advanced to increase the proactiveness of frontline sites.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.