The 'Chasing Trade' Trap: Why Individual Investors Lose Money Even When Returns Are High
Song Tae-heon, a product strategy expert at Shinhan Asset Management, warns that individual investors often fall into the trap of "chasing trades," entering the market when returns are at their peak due to FOMO. He emphasizes that successful wealth management relies on managing principal, returns, and most importantly, time to harness the power of compound interest.
A phenomenon is repeatedly occurring where investment products report high returns, yet the actual accounts of investors record losses. This is due to "chasing trades," where investors jump into a product after its performance has already reached its peak. Song Tae-heon, a product strategy expert at Shinhan Asset Management with 23 years of experience, analyzed why individual investors repeatedly lose money and discussed the essence of wealth management during a conversation with The Man Who Explains the Economy (Kim Kwang-seok TV).
'FOMO' at the Peak of Returns... Why Individual Investors Lose Money
Song pointed out a significant gap between the reported returns of an investment product and the actual returns experienced by the investor. While public interest is low immediately after a product is created, the product becomes widely known through the media and experts once returns begin to surge. It is at this point that investors begin to study and take interest.
The problem lies in the timing of when investors complete their study. "By the time investors start studying, the market price has often already risen once more," Song explained. "When returns have already risen sufficiently, the FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out) psychology kicks in, leading to a late influx of large-scale capital."
In this process, investors enter at high prices. Even if the market enters a correction phase and the product's returns drop slightly, individual investors who entered at the peak face losses on their principal. In particular, because they often use leverage to invest large amounts due to the anxiety of being late, they fall into a vicious cycle where the scale of losses becomes even larger. Song noted that these mistakes are being repeated, citing examples of China funds in the 2000s and recent leveraged products.
Additionally, the "loss aversion effect," a psychological trap, was identified as a major reason why investors fail to stick to investment principles. Even when they should cut losses upon recognizing them, many fall into a psychological trap by choosing "averaging down" (additional buying) to recover losses instead.
"Finance Textbooks are Corporate-Centric"... The Need for 'Principles of Money' for Individuals
Song cited the "absence of financial education" as the fundamental cause of these repeated mistakes. "Schools teach theories like supply and demand curves, but they do not teach the basic skills of wealth management that individuals actually need to use in practice," he said. He pointed out that even university-level finance theories are written from a corporate perspective, which limits their understanding for individuals.
He reinterpreted the first principle of finance, the "time value of money," from the perspective of an individual. The value of money changes over time, and the key to managing it lies in "time." For example, 10 million won placed in a safe 10 years ago has much less purchasing power when converted to current value considering inflation. In other words, the most important variable in increasing the value of money is time.
Song warned that it is dangerous to define wealth management simply as "the act of maximizing returns (r)." He defined the essence of wealth management as the management of three elements: ▲management of investment principal, ▲management of returns, and most importantly, ▲management of time. "When people think of wealth management, it is easy to think only of making returns large, but in reality, the essence is managing these three together," he emphasized.
The Power to Wait for the Magic of Compound Interest... Wealth Management that Manages 'Time'
Compound interest, a core principle of wealth management, is a structure where assets increase exponentially as interest is added to interest. However, Song emphasized that a period of patience is essential before this compound interest effect appears. This is because the section where assets increase rapidly in an exponential form, rather than a linear one, usually appears after 20 to 25 years have passed.
"Most investors cannot endure this waiting period," he said. "The impatience to achieve economic freedom immediately conflicts with the principles of money." He emphasized the importance of long-term investment, comparing it to how an apple tree must go through a long preparation period to bear fruit.
Song expressed confidence in long-term investment. "I have yet to see anyone who invested for the long term and suffered a loss," he said, explaining that unlike short-term investment, long-term investment is based on the powerful principle of compound interest. Ultimately, Song concluded that successful wealth management is not about chasing high returns by rushing into the market, but about protecting the principal and securing enough time for compound interest to work.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.