South Korea considers commission cap as platform fees hit 30% of revenue
As the National Assembly of the Republic of Korea discusses a "commission cap" to limit delivery app fees to 15%, concerns are rising over whether the costs will ultimately be shifted to consumers or riders.
The National Assembly is discussing a bill to cap delivery app fees at 15% to protect small business owners. However, concerns have emerged that such regulations could lead to higher consumer costs and reduced rider income, similar to outcomes observed in some United States cities.
As movements to legally limit the brokerage commissions of delivery platforms begin, the interests of restaurant owners, delivery platforms, riders, and consumers are becoming intricately intertwined. With the National Assembly of the Republic of Korea discussing the introduction of a "commission cap" to limit delivery app fees to a maximum of 15%, the possibility of actual cost shifting resulting from the regulation has emerged as a key issue.
If a 20,000 won meal is sold, 6,200 won evaporates... platform costs account for 30% of revenue
According to an analysis provided by Understanding: All the Knowledge in the World, the costs currently borne by restaurant owners using delivery platforms account for a significant portion of their revenue. Looking at the case of a gukbap restaurant in the metropolitan area, the cost structure an owner must bear when receiving an order worth 20,000 won is very harsh.
First, since the brokerage commissions for Baemin and Coupang Eats are set at approximately 7.8%, about 1,560 won is deducted from a 20,000 won sale as a base. Considering that the delivery fee borne by the owner is about 3,000 won per order, more than 22% of the revenue—approximately 4,500 won—is already going toward platform-related costs. The situation becomes more serious when advertising costs spent to expose the restaurant are added. In the case of this gukbap restaurant, which spends about 1,688 won in advertising per order, approximately 6,200 won out of the 20,000 won revenue is ultimately lost to platform costs. This means more than 30% of the revenue is spent on platform-related expenses.
Owners must cover all food ingredient costs, rent, labor, electricity, and water from this low-30% range of costs. Voices from the field suggest that because they must continue operations with the remaining 70% after excluding platform costs, it is a structure in which it is very difficult to generate profit.
Concerns over 'delivery fee hikes' and 'reduced rider income' upon introduction of commission cap
To resolve these issues, the National Assembly Political Affairs Committee is discussing bills such as limiting the sum of brokerage commissions, advertising fees, and payment fees (approximately 3%) to within 15%. This bill, which is scheduled for review by the standing committee at the end of this month, aims to protect small business owners, but concerns are also rising regarding the side effects that may occur if the regulation is introduced. This is because platform companies may raise delivery fees for consumers or lower the delivery fees paid to riders to compensate for the reduced profits caused by the limited commissions.
In fact, cases in some cities in the United States are highly suggestive. Although a commission cap for delivery apps has been implemented in some areas of the United States since 2021, related research showed side effects such as the consumer burden increasing by an average of 4.6 dollars (approximately 6,200 won) and order volumes decreasing. Consequently, the analysis suggests that while the profits of restaurant owners may improve slightly, the overall economic welfare of society actually decreases. Riders are also concerned that the commission cap will lead to a reduction in delivery fees and are arguing that a "guaranteed minimum delivery fee per order" clause must be prepared alongside it. There is anxiety that if commissions are suppressed, the rider's delivery fee may decrease if the delivery fee is included within the commission.
Commission rates 'matching' amid free delivery competition... promoting market competition is key
One of the structural problems in the delivery market is that the fierce competition among major platforms, such as Baemin and Coupang Eats, has actually led to a downward equalization of commission rates. In early 2024, as Coupang Eats entered the market by expanding its free delivery service for consumers, Baemin immediately moved to respond. In this process, consumers enjoyed free delivery benefits through Baemin Club or Coupang Eats WOW membership, but the platforms showed a pattern of increasing commission rates for owners to match those of their competitors.
Indeed, in March 2024, Baemin increased the commission for owners from the previous 6.8% to 9.8% to align with its competitor. Currently, it operates a "Win-Win Fee System" that applies a 7.8% commission to the bottom 85% of small restaurants with low revenue, but it is being pointed out that rather than actual price competition between platforms, they appear to be matching each other's rates. Experts suggest that rather than a regulation that simply sets a ceiling on commissions, fundamental measures are needed to promote actual competition between platforms and thereby increase the bargaining power of restaurants.
Ultimately, who bears the cost?
The issue of delivery app commissions ultimately boils down to the question of who among restaurant owners, riders, and consumers will finally bear the costs incurred, beyond the size of the profits taken by the platforms. Consumers have been unknowingly enjoying benefits provided by platforms, such as free delivery, so their voices are relatively low regarding commission regulation; however, the core variable of this legislative controversy is that if the cost shifting caused by regulation becomes a reality, the arrow may turn back toward the consumers. Ultimately, deciding the subject of the cost burden within the delivery food ecosystem is the core of this discussion.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.