Korean retirees need different withdrawal rates than US 4% rule
The Mirae Asset Investment and Pension Center has released a report seeking to determine an appropriate withdrawal rate for Korean retirees, noting that the widely used US-based "4% rule" may not be directly applicable to the Korean financial market.
The Mirae Asset Investment and Pension Center has released a report seeking a "Korean-style" withdrawal rate, noting that the US-based 4% rule is difficult to apply directly to the Korean market due to differences in stock and bond volatility.
How much should retirees withdraw from their accumulated assets each year to sustain their livelihood without exhausting their funds? Analysis suggests that beyond simply saving money, a strategic approach is required regarding how remaining assets are managed and withdrawn.
The Mirae Asset Investment and Pension Center recently released the findings of a study to find an appropriate withdrawal rate for Korean retirees in the "Mirae Asset Investment and Pension Report No. 71." Subtitled "Retirement Assets: How to manage them to withdraw more? (Subtitle: Searching for the appropriate withdrawal rate for Korean retirees)," the report focuses on variables faced after retirement, such as the need for continuous living expenses for 30 years or more due to increased life expectancy, the decline in real purchasing power caused by inflation, and unexpected costs like medical or care expenses.
"Adjusting the first year's withdrawal for inflation"... The core of the 4% rule is a 'safety device'
The most widely cited standard when discussing retirement asset withdrawal strategies is the "4% rule," which originated from a 1994 study by US financial planner William Bengen. The withdrawal rate refers to the percentage of total retirement assets withdrawn in the first year of retirement. For example, if retirement assets are 100 million won and 10 million won is withdrawn in the first year, the withdrawal rate is 10%.
Crucially, this does not mean recalculating a certain percentage of the remaining assets every year. According to Bengen's method, after determining the first year's withdrawal amount, the amount withdrawn in subsequent years is increased only by the rate of inflation. This serves as a mechanism to prevent living expenses from fluctuating wildly based on market conditions, which would make a stable retirement difficult if one were to suddenly increase spending when asset prices rise or significantly decrease it when the market falls.
Bengen used historical US stock and bond returns and inflation data to analyze how long assets would last depending on when retirement began. By applying a method of holding both stocks and bonds and adjusting the initial withdrawal rate for inflation, he examined whether assets would be exhausted over a 30-year period. The results showed that even at very unfavorable retirement starting points in the past, assets could be maintained with an initial withdrawal rate of approximately 4%, leading Bengen to call an initial withdrawal rate of 2% to 4% a "safe withdrawal rate."
However, because this figure is a very conservative standard, it is characterized by the fact that significant assets may remain even after the retirement period ends. Lee Jeong-won, a senior researcher at the Mirae Asset Investment and Pension Center, explained in the video that rather than viewing 4% as a mandatory answer for everyone, it is better to understand it as a representative benchmark for judging how long assets can be maintained while using a certain amount of living expenses.
The 4% rule based on US data is difficult to apply directly to the Korean market
The problem is that it is difficult to apply the 4% rule, which was designed based on US market data from 30 years ago, directly to the current Korean financial environment. This is because the long-term returns and volatility of the stock market, as well as the bond market environment, are fundamentally different between Korea and the US. If the characteristics of the invested market differ, the duration of asset maintenance or the possibility of exhaustion can change completely even if the same withdrawal rate is applied.
"The financial market environments of Korea and the US are not the same," noted senior researcher Lee Jeong-won. "Ultimately, if the market being invested in changes, the period assets are maintained or the possibility of exhaustion can also change." The explanation is that rather than accepting 4% as an absolute answer, it is more accurate to consider what assets are being invested in, what retirement period is assumed, and how much risk of asset exhaustion one is willing to accept.
In fact, Bengen has explained in follow-up studies that a higher safe withdrawal rate may be possible by expanding the range of investment targets, and research based on expected future returns or specific success probabilities has presented rates that are lower than or similar to 4%.
A new approach to deriving a Korean-style appropriate withdrawal rate
Accordingly, this report focused on deriving a "Korean-style appropriate withdrawal rate" that reflects the conditions of the Korean financial market, moving beyond US-based standards. Since Bengen's research was conducted based on US market data, rather than applying it directly to Korean retirees, the report separately identified how much can be withdrawn by considering Korean stock returns, volatility, and the bond environment.
Ultimately, a retirement asset withdrawal strategy is more than just a number calculating living expenses; it serves as a standard for determining how much can be withdrawn while investing the remaining assets to maintain them for the required period. A Korean-style withdrawal strategy, which varies depending on which asset classes a retiree invests in and how much asset exhaustion risk they are willing to take, is expected to become a key indicator for future retirement planning.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.