Individual investors face structural disadvantages and psychological traps in markets
Economic journalist Kim Won-jang analyzed the structural and psychological reasons why individual investors repeatedly lose in a market designed to favor those with massive capital.
Economic journalist Kim Won-jang warned that individual investors struggle against massive capital entities like BlackRock, noting that household interest burdens increase by approximately 3 trillion won when rates rise. He advised investors to seek warnings of market declines rather than comfort to avoid the pitfalls of confirmation bias.
The capital market is by no means a level playing field. A massive difference in "weight class" exists between those who move enormous capital and individual investors, and the very structure of the market is designed to favor those with capital. During a recent discussion with 'The Man Who Explains the Economy (Kim Kwang-seok TV)', Kim Won-jang, an economic journalist with 30 years of experience, analyzed the structural and psychological reasons why individual investors are destined to repeatedly lose in the market.
"Flyweight fighting heavyweights"... the capital gap is a structural inevitability
Journalist Kim pointed out that the market is overwhelmingly advantageous to those who possess capital. "The market is too favorable to those with a lot of capital," he noted, diagnosing that the massive wealth gap has grown large enough to make one question the continued maintenance of the market economy. Citing Bank of Korea Governor Rhee Chang-yong's explanation that household loans are approaching 2,000 trillion won and that interest burdens for households increase by about 3 trillion won when interest rates rise, Kim highlighted that many people face increased interest burdens during periods of rate hikes.
In particular, Kim analyzed the principles of liquidity expansion and asset value appreciation, explaining that as M2 (broad money) in the market continues to increase, nominal values are bound to rise. "We all talk about apartments in nominal terms," he said, explaining that even without considering real purchasing power, asset owners are in a favorable position to accumulate vast wealth through capital gains. Drawing a parallel to the setting of the novel 'Pride and Prejudice', he added that just as aristocrats in the past accumulated wealth through farming or capital gains, the modern market economy also operates to the advantage of those with capital.
Kim emphasized the difference in weight class between individuals and the massive capital moving on Wall Street. "Who pays the salaries and the helicopter fuel for people commuting to Wall Street from New Jersey by helicopter? Ultimately, it is the money issued by the central bank, which is equivalent to taking money from market participants," he explained. Comparing this to combat sports, he added, "It is like a fight between a flyweight and a heavyweight. It is by no means easy for an individual investor to generate profits against giant capital such as The Carlyle Group or BlackRock." He suggested that when buying Samsung Electronics stock, it is extremely difficult for an individual's judgment to prevail when titans like Henry Kravis or George Obeocheu judge that "it is the bottom, so let's sell."
"Listen to advice that things will fall, instead of comfort that they will rise"
As much as the structural disadvantage, "psychological traps" also destroy individuals. Kim criticized many investors for falling into "confirmation bias," where they enthusiastically follow experts who predict rises because they want their holdings to go up, while leaving malicious comments for experts who warn of declines.
"You need someone who gives advice, not someone who gives comfort," he advised. "If you strongly believe something will rise, you should instead actively seek out the opinions of those saying it will fall." This is because the market moves based on people's minds rather than actual value. "Wishes, prayers, and desires are not rewarded. You are only rewarded with money when our investment is correct," he said, emphasizing cool-headed judgment to avoid being swept up in market trends. He stated, "Those who overcome the trend are the ones who earn," warning against the behavior of impulsively jumping into the market.
Investment methods resembling the psychology of picking lottery numbers
Kim compared the investment behavior of individual investors to the psychology of people buying lottery tickets. Just as people do not look for numbers with a high probability of winning, but instead prefer numbers that have won frequently in the past or familiar numbers like birthdays, investors move according to popular trends and their own desires rather than statistical or scientific evidence. "We are beings who even sign up as paid members to receive lottery numbers that have no probability," he remarked, pointing out how irrational the way people participate in the market can be.
Using the example of 'Russian roulette', he warned that surviving twelve times with a six-shot revolver does not increase the probability of survival in the next round. Even though the survival probability for the thirteenth round remains only one-sixth, people rely on past luck to face the next round. Kim concluded that "we must start by admitting how haphazardly we are participating in the market," stating that the core of investing is controlling one's mind so as not to lose to market desires.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.