Reporter warns investors against mistaking luck for skill
Reporter Kim Won-jang shares insights on investor psychology, warning that market participants often mistake luck for skill and fall into psychological traps during periods of high volatility.
Reporter Kim Won-jang warned that investors often mistake luck for skill during bull markets, noting that the 2015 Shanghai stock market surge saw millions of new accounts opened as people rushed to invest.
Everyone becomes a genius during a bull market. When the market heats up, investors dive in believing they are analysts, but they are often the first to collapse when the market cools. A discussion by reporter Kim Won-jang, shared by The Man Who Explains the Economy (Kim Kwang-seok TV), contains insights into the "investor's mind," which is more important than reading market trends.
"The most dangerous moment is when everyone believes they must buy"
Reporter Kim Won-jang emphasizes that market movements should be viewed from a psychological perspective rather than through the laws of physics. Quoting the maxim, "When everyone agrees, the market disagrees," he explained that the period when all investors rush in feeling FOMO (fear of missing out) may actually be the period when the market provides a reversal. Conversely, a phase where everyone thinks they should leave the market could be the period where the market moves in the opposite direction.
In fact, the case of the Shanghai stock market surge in 2015 serves as a classic example of a "human indicator." At that time, an investment craze swept China, with millions of securities accounts being opened in a single month. The video recounted that offline investing was so active at Shanghai securities firms that even monks participated in investing with their robes exposed. Furthermore, it was recalled that at People's Square, hundreds of people would gather to preach their investment methods to the public, mentioning connections to specific companies or investing by analyzing the I Ching.
While it is easy to fall into the illusion of being a genius who sees through the market during a bull market, Kim points out that such indicators can only be realized after the market has already passed. This psychological overheating tends to move in the opposite direction of the market's true heading. Quoting the Governor of the Bank of Korea, Kim used a metaphor: "Forecasting the market is like sitting in a reverse seat on a KTX and looking out the window." While the path already traveled can be analyzed with statistics, no one can be certain of the scenery that will unfold ahead. In a situation where even central banks confess the difficulty of predicting the future, investors must be wary of the psychology of feeling they have made money simply because stock prices rose.
The 'Leverage Trap' of failing to distinguish luck from skill
The point investors must be most wary of is the moment they mistake "luck" for "skill." Kim emphasized the importance of clearly distinguishing how much was skill and how much was luck, warning that even if a profit is made, one must clearly differentiate whether it was a structural profit based on one's own analysis or simply luck from riding a market trend. In particular, he noted that if profits were made during a period like the first half of this year when specific stocks rose, one must recognize the high possibility that it was luck rather than skill.
While claiming to aim for long-term investment, he pointed out the psychological vicious cycle of investors who check charts every day and feel anxious. When they invest in large-cap stocks and the prices do not move, they feel impatient and eventually buy leveraged ETFs. They then end up losing a significant portion of their principal in just a few days when those leveraged ETFs plummet. He added that the sight of people switching to even more speculative "bomb stocks" and learning about forced liquidations or capital reductions in practice is a repetitive cycle he has witnessed over the past 30 years. Ultimately, at the end of this process, investors leave the path of investing while criticizing themselves.
Through the past case of Hynix (now SK hynix), he redefined the meaning of skill. Citing the case of a famous figure who made massive profits by investing in Hynix decades ago, Kim analyzed that the true ability of that person was not in picking the right stock, but in the "attitude" of securing sufficient seed money, keeping reliable advisors close, trusting them, being patient for a long time, and diversifying investments. He explained that even during periods of extreme volatility, such as when Hynix faced the risk of being sold to Micron in 2001 or when SK Telecom's credit rating was downgraded, the true skill lay in enduring based on sufficient assets and advisors.
"Price prediction is impossible; study is needed to identify position"
While many investors rely on experts' "price predictions," Kim says the attempt to hit a price is reckless. Given that even the Fed Chair cannot accurately predict bond rates six months ahead, it is nearly impossible to hit market prices, which have no fixed laws like physics due to the intervention of human emotions.
He classified the roles of economic experts into two types: "path analysts," who analyze where the current market is positioned, where the ship is heading, and whether there is enough food (liquidity), and "predictors," who try to guess what the price will be. Kim mentioned that the latter role is not a good fit and advised that studying the position and structure of the market is the correct attitude for an investor to take.
Ultimately, the success or failure of an investment depends more on controlling one's mind than on technical analysis. Kim emphasized that "I have never seen a long-term investor who typically loses money," noting that unlike short-term investors, it is important for long-term investors to maintain strategic direction and target rates of return. Even if investors react sensitively to immediate volatility and feel anxious rather than focusing on mid-to-long-term outlooks, the core of investing is to drop one's own psychological anchor and regulate one's mind.
Source: original video (YouTube)
0Comments
Comments are currently disabled.